'Modern-day book burners': Portland bookstore forced to evacuate after protesters demand it pulls book critical of Antifa
Powell’s City of Books in Portland, one of the world’s largest independent bookstores, had to evacuate repeatedly after it was besieged by protesters enraged over its plans to sell a book claiming Antifa is “destroying democracy.”
A crowd of protesters flocked to the store on Monday to denounce its decision to distribute a book by a local author, conservative journalist Andy Ngo, known for documenting and highlighting instances of violence associated with Antifa on social media. The owners were forced to evacuate employees and customers out the back door. Later that day, the store announced it would not be putting the book on the shelves, but that it would remain in its online catalogue, along with many books that Powell’s itself deems “abhorrent.”
This book will not be placed on our shelves. We will not promote it. That said, it will remain in our online catalog. We carry a lot of books we find abhorrent, as well as those that we treasure. (2 of 3)
— Powell's Books (@Powells) January 11, 2021
“While we understand that our decision to carry such books upsets some customers and staff members, we do not want to create an echo chamber of preapproved voices and ideas,” the company said.
However, that concession apparently failed to placate all of the protesters, as a smaller crowd was back at the store the next day, chanting slogans and vowing to force the store out of business if it failed to exercise self-censorship.
The store is EMPTY.
A former employee has told me that the Powell’s fired an employee that had been doxed by Andy
— Andy Ngo's book is nazi propaganda (@it_aint_pretty_) January 11, 2021
“You will lose money every day. Every day that you sell his book, we will shut down this store,” protesters could be heard shouting in footage circulating online.
Powell’s was forced to close early and evacuate customers on Tuesday as well.
Antifa have forced Powell's to close their store today and employees have evacuated the customers inside out the back door. They're protesting them selling Andy Ngo's book on their website. They announced earlier they wouldn't put it on the shelves.pic.twitter.com/HUwea0pdei
— Brittany (@Brittany3l) January 11, 2021
Set for release in February, the book – titled ‘Unmasked: Inside Antifa’s Radical Plan to Destroy Democracy’ – chronicles Antifa’s history of violence and its “radical plan to destroy democracy.” It is touted as an in-depth study of the origins and the history of the left-wing movement that features accounts by former supporters, as well as those who fell victim to its violence. The book is said to contain “a trove of documents obtained by the author that he will publish for the first time,” according to Amazon’s description of the tome.
While some critics of the book and the store itself have accused Powell’s of giving a platform to “fascists and racists,” others argued that Ngo had endangered protesters by exposing them, insisting that freedom of speech doesn’t protect the book since it could “incite actions that would harm others.”
It's the work of bookselling and booksellers to give fascists and racists a place to air their views? Bold take.
— Sleve McDichael (@onezeroronny) January 11, 2021
HATE SPEECH IS NOT FREE SPEECH
community over capitalism.
— Kelsey Anderson 🌹 (@____kelsbby) January 11, 2021
You cited freedom of speech as the reason you kept it on your virtual shelf. According to the Supreme Court, freedom of speech does not include the right to incite actions that would harm others — Schenck v. United States.
Please remove this dangerous book. (3 of 3)
— Regina Ligon (@ReginaMLigon) January 11, 2021
Ngo’s supporters, on the other hand, decried the efforts to block the book’s distribution, calling the protesters “modern-day book burners.”
Cowards. Modern day book burners
— Sharks Fan 1991 (@SharksFan1991) January 12, 2021
“There are few acts of censorship as overt as a mob deciding which books people should be allowed to read,” wrote author and Reason journalist Robby Soave.
There are few acts of censorship as overt as a mob deciding which books people should be allowed to read. Ladies and gentlemen, antifa. https://t.co/pNdQKIw7SY
— Robby Soave (@robbysoave) January 12, 2021
Ngo, who is Asian, came to increased prominence after he was attacked by a mob of Antifa protesters while covering a rally in 2019.
Like this story? Share it with a friend!